Skip to content

Fencing

Pressure-treated posts vs cedar

Are pressure-treated fence posts bad?

Pressure-treated wood resists rot but does not stop it, and the treatment is weakest exactly where the post needs it most — at the soil line. That's why we don't set fences on them.

Where posts actually rot

A post does not rot evenly. It rots in a band a few inches above and below where the wood meets the dirt, because that's the only part of the post that is simultaneously wet, warm, and exposed to air. Bury it deeper and that band just moves down with it.

Everything above that band can look perfect. That's what makes it deceptive — the fence looks fine right up until a decent wind takes a section down, and the break is always at the dirt line.

What the treatment actually does

Pressure treatment forces preservative into the outer layer of the wood. It genuinely slows decay, and for a deck joist that stays dry and ventilated it is the right material.

A fence post is a different problem. It is buried, it stays damp, and any cut end or drilled hole opens untreated wood straight to the soil. The protection is a shell, and burying the post is how you find the parts the shell doesn't cover.

What we use instead

Steel posts, or cedar set properly in concrete with the crown shaped so water runs away from the post rather than pooling against it.

The cost difference shows up once, at install. The difference in outcome shows up at year six, when one fence is leaning and the other isn't.

Rot is patient. Build like it's coming, because it is.

Questions

Can a pressure-treated post be saved once it starts to go?
No. Once the section at the soil line is soft, the post is structurally done. What's left is deciding whether to replace that post or the run.
Are steel posts worth it?
For a fence you intend to keep, yes. Steel takes the rot question off the table entirely and lets the cedar be a finish material instead of a structural one.

Start here

Tell us what you want built.

Send the details. We'll set up a time to come walk it.

Call 469-887-1100Get a quote